Spencer Shrader is the Indianapolis Colts number 3 kicker, a second-year pro, and finished the 2025 regular season as a streaming-viable fantasy option at his position. He averaged 11.0 fantasy points per game across 5 appearances, which ranks him 3rd among kickers in our 2026 draft board. That per-game number is the starting point for every start or sit decision you make with him in 2026.
Spencer Shrader produced steady fantasy output in 2025 with 11.0 PPG over 5 games.
Spencer Shrader is a key fantasy asset whose role and production make him a weekly lineup decision.
Heading into 2026, Spencer Shrader projects as a core piece of the Indianapolis Colts offense. Managers drafting him need to plan around his Week 13 bye and monitor training camp reports for role changes. DraftCall's AI comparison engine lets you pit him against any other NFL player in seconds, factoring in matchup quality, recent form, and scoring format, so you can make start or sit calls with real reasoning instead of gut feel.
